Skip to content
Tailor & Barber Tailor & Barber

A men's lifestyle blog focusing on style, fashion, and grooming.

  • Home
  • Shave and Groom
    • Fragrance
    • Shaving Soap
    • Shaving Cream
    • Aftershave
    • Safety Razor
    • Shaving Brush
    • Hair
    • Shave of the Day
    • Shave Oil
  • Style Thoughts
    • Outfit of the Day
    • Outfit Inspiration
    • The Look for Less
    • Three Ways
    • Suits
    • Sport Coat
    • Pants
    • Shirts
    • Shoes
    • Outerwear
    • Sweaters
    • Jeans
    • Underwear
  • Shop the Feed
  • Required Reading
  • Contact
Tailor & Barber
Tailor & Barber

A men's lifestyle blog focusing on style, fashion, and grooming.

Spier & Mackay Sweater Review

Spier & Mackay Sweater Review

Posted on January 13, 2020January 12, 2020 By Drew

I think sweaters are the ultimate pairing of comfort and style. I don’t need to wear a restrictive button-up shirt underneath if I don’t want to. Even when I do, I leave the top button unbuttoned. I can even escape the choking neck tie if I want to. Of course, the more I wear ties, the less I feel like I’m being choked. And proper fitting shirts are a sure cure for uncomfortable clothes. However, I can say with certainty that a softer neck, like on a sweater, is generally more comfortable, and I don’t think I have to sacrifice style when wearing one. Over the past few months, I’ve added four Spier & Mackay sweaters, all cable-knit, and I wanted to share my thoughts.

Crewneck Sweaters

Spier & Mackay Sweater Review
Spier & Mackay Sweater Review

Sweater: Spier & Mackay  // Shirt: Brooks Brothers

Jeans: imogene + willie  // Shoes: Beckett Simonon  // Sunglasses: Persol

I unabashedly love cable knit, crewneck sweaters. They’re so versatile. I typically wear cotton or linen in the summer, and wool in the winter. Depending on the weather I can wear them with an undershirt, a polo shirt, a button-up short, or even nothing (in the summer) underneath. What I wear underneath can shift the entire vibe of my outfit from tropical casual to holiday dress, all with the same sweater.

These Spier & Mackay cable-knit sweaters are wonderful in all the right ways. The neck isn’t too big, so when I wear one with an undershirt, the undershirt doesn’t show (one of my biggest style pet peeves). These sweater collars also play well with other collared shirts too. They sit well and let everything lay as it should. As far as fit is concerned, they are not too slim (which I like), and the sleeves are the right length and not too long like some brands tend to be, especially at larger sizes like my XXL. With just the right amount of stretch, these sweaters are an exceptional value under $100.

I do one to point out one more thing about one of the crewneck sweaters I purchased. A few wears in, the seam opened up under my left arm. I contacted Spier & Mackay, and they immediately offered to replace the sweater with a new one. The service and response time were both excellent; Spier & Mackay couldn’t have handled it any better. Things happen, it’s all about how a brand responds in my opinion.

Turtleneck Sweaters

Spier & Mackay Sweater Review
Spier & Mackay Sweater Review

Sweater: Spier & Mackay  // Trousers: Suitsupply

Shoes: Beckett Simonon  // Sunglasses: Persol

To be totally honest, I was pretty nervous about trying turtlenecks. I don’t know if I had ever worn one before this. I don’t have a small build, and I Was afraid they would make me look too puffy. Dead wrong. These turtlenecks were so soft and so comfortable. The neck roll was big enough to be proportional to my large melon head. Plus, they’re warmer than the crewnecks with a rollback that traps the heat, so I’m able to wear the turtlenecks on colder days. If you thought turtlenecks were only for Bond villains, think again. These are some incredibly stylish sweaters that you need all winter. 

My recommendation for both sweaters is to buy two and get the bundle pricing. You’re going to want a second one.

Outfit Inspiration Style Thoughts Sweaters beckBrooks Brothersimogene + williePersolSpier & MackaySuitsupply

Post navigation

Previous post
Next post

Related Posts

Shirts A Tale of Four Oxford Button Down Shirts

A Tale of Four Oxford Button Down Shirts

Posted on October 6, 2020October 5, 2020

October is here. Summer is over. Cue the menswear memes about fall coming and finally being able to start dressin’. One of the most iconic pieces of fall and winter clothing is the Oxford button down. These shirts are as stylish when paired with a flannel suit as they are…

Read More
Style Thoughts

Outfit Inspiration: A Mackintosh Jacket Two Ways

Posted on September 22, 2016November 15, 2017

Monday’s downpour reminded that those rainy fall days are coming. I love autumn, but I struggle with dressing stylishly for the rain. I can never seem to find a middle ground.

Read More
Outfit Inspiration

Outfit Inspiration: Selvedge Twill Pants or Chinos

Posted on February 14, 2017November 15, 2017

A few weeks ago I took a trip to the King of Prussia Brooks Brother’s store in search of some new chino pants. As a longtime customer of BB, I know they’re one of the best places to shop for men’s pants.

Read More

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Threads
  • X
  • Pinterest
  • Facebook

Subscribe

Recent Posts

  • My 2025 Style Resolutions
  • 3 Everyday Fragrances for Men
  • Why I Hate Stretch Fabric
  • My Casual Vacation Travel Kit
  • New Year’s Resolutions for 2023
©2025 Tailor & Barber | WordPress Theme by SuperbThemes
 

Loading Comments...